after a welcome from Lawrence and a very fun upbeat song and dance number by student
proposed regulations can be found here
now being prepared for state college or postsecondary "depends too much on the high school that they go to"
"what high schools must offer, not what individual students must complete to graduate"
"the time and structure"
from early literacy "even though we tried through many incentives [to get districts to adopt]...saw the frustration with the legislature"
that is to presume that any of this is correct; one can be frustrated that things aren't done, and those not doing it know better
want to avoid that as graduation standards become law
this presumes the Legislature will agree with the graduation report and DESE...which is a large leap
"a real structured process for planning for what comes after high school"
"a student's access shouldn't depend on their zip code" and they are doing nothing to address the actual challenges here
tie back to this being from graduation report with much discussion of this coming from public comment and a "robust process of stakeholder engagement" which leaves out that the final report very specifically came only from the Secretary and the Commissioner
MassCore aligned with state college admission; "backed by research" (there's a slight weird correlation rather than causation thing happening here); "should compete each MassCore subject" surveys showed; 70% of districts either require or are one course short
roughly 1/3 of schools in 30% of schools are alternative and need support; remainder are varied, so not a single group, evenly distributed by size or geography
will need to focus on alternative schools
MyCAP: year-by-year planning; "who am I, where am I going, how do I get there"
regular reflection; go back to core questions and reflect on what has changed
"established but not yet universal"
more than 40% have "engaged in planning and grants" which tells us nothing of how many are doing it
collecting "graduation readiness and planning data" by December (it's due towards the end of this month)
plan is to send out for public comment December; vote in March
"we do anticipate this legislation coming soon" I do not know what this expectation would be based on, as that is not at all how the Legislature works. At all. In any way.
interest, strengths, skills, secondary course work and experiences, document of progress towards graduation and completion
must include
- a. Development of financial literacy knowledge and skills;
- b. Development of artificial intelligence and digital literacy knowledge and skills;
- c. Engagement in a work-based learning experience; and
- d. Completion of the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) or the Massachusetts Application for State Financial Aid (MASFA), or opting-out.
by Sept 27, every district has to have MassCore; by Sept 28, every district has to have MyCAP
DESE will audit
"don't have a problem with the policy; it's the implementation"
before next meeting would appreciate getting some understanding of "how we have the legislative authority to do this" ahhh
"just want to ensure we aren't overstepping even a flexible" evaluation of the law
Woo: have done a legal analysis, confident have authority to require offer but not of individual students
yeah I'd be interested in seeing where they're getting that one, too
Hills: regulation something that will result in inequities
"wavier our way out of"
basis on which we're okay with this, don't want to waiver our way out of it
"at least two things can be true: a lot of students will be better off as they go through this process," some will get pigeonholed "on ways that pretty tough when you're 13, 14, 15 years old"
"they're locking themselves into something early, whether it is intentional or not"
Woo: intend to get from districts some insight into what districts are experiencing
provision in regs provides for flexibility
West: appreciate rhythm in going through the topics and the presentation
strongest case is to help schools prepare for a student-level requirement that we expect to come
they do?
should reg be written more indirectly, then?
share what the audits might look like in December meeting
moves much faster than graduation report does; districts across the Commonwealth are preparing budgets amid significant fiscal pressures, raises practical implementation questions for me
DESE keeps talking about "offering" rather than what students require
"distinction appears central to DESE's legal and policy use"
Limits of actual distinction legally
moving from recommendation to statewide regulation "represents a significant policy shift"
operational, fiscal, and legal implications
"why is this proposal property implemented through an accelerated timeline" rather than through legislation and a proper timeline
Craven: accelerated timeline will get feedback
Martinez: timelines are more aligned than not because the actual shifts to the budget "which we're very sensitive to"
there's a two to three year runway this is not true, as there are things required next fall
courses that meet criteria rather than not
"nothing would change for districts for next year" as districts have to meet 9th and 10th grade today
Fisher: speak to Hills concern on pigeonholing students
doing work with high school students "since late 1900s"
going into fifth and sixth grade with districts that can't afford to do it on their own
"if done in isolation without conversation, bad things can happen with these instruments"
show interest with connection to possible postsecondary options
if done correctly increases student engagement; engage everyone in process
"if done correctly, it's an awesome thing; if done poorly, it can be a problem"
Mohamed: the process is so much more important than the product
where are the bottlenecks in the process?
have heard of shortage of guidance counselors
Martinez: MassCore and MyCap "had support across the board"
support from counselors' association
Craven: if there were some carrot rather than just the stick of an audit
"we struggle" with dissemination of best practices
"I know that we want to be more than just compliance as an agency"
Zrike: good questions about resources; role to advocate on resources
"it's a mindset shift"
Before adding more people, "this work should be owned by everybody"
it is hard to "own" work that is being assigned and for which you didn't sign up
"have to help mindset shift" before we "add hundreds of people"
Not to say schools won't need people
counselors often feel isolated tremedously
"trying to serve hundreds of kids that's unsustainable"
"necessary to give
"purpose of schooling is to prepare students for their future" hmmm how
"responsible for career and college planning in ways we traditional have not done well enough"
only issue would have for schools to adopt curricula but if that's already covered...
No comments:
Post a Comment