Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Board of Ed for November: opening comments

 The Board of Elementary and Secondary Education meets today at 9 in Lawrence. The agenda is here; the livestream is here. 

As I noted earlier, Chair Katherine Craven is making part of her opening comments a "Holocaust and Genocide Education Board Committee," harkening back to the Open Meeting Law violation of the Board regarding this same topic, when they deliberated public comment the Chair specifically invited on this topic. 

I will update this as we go, though I am not promising to catch every in and out of public comment remotely...

Public comment

Lynn panel, testifying on translation and interpretation (as updated by state regulation) "we are committed to quality document translation" but concerned about requirement that all machine translation of special education be reviewed by humans before being given to families
Law "does not require human review of machine technology"
"just not enough staff or vendor services" and would cost $4M
"impossible to comply with" as cannot comply with timelines for non-English speaking families
shortage of translators
"unfeasible and have unintended consequences"
"think there are some easy fixes"
that was a deliberate and considered change to the regulation, however

Newton parent Sana Fadel
panel in 2024 violating OML
"here to ask Chair Craven if she will be using her time to violate" the OML again
will the panel acknowledge the split in genocide scholars about Palestine or platform organizations that deny that and claim it is blood libel
will organizations be platformed that libel teachers as ignorant or even antisemitic
"is it something that is hidden under your comment because" it will be hidden
"Please do not use your position to advance your own political goals"

Somerville parent Gretchen Brion-Meisels, granddaughter of Holocaust survivors
safe and inclusive schools for adolescents
"unclear what the chair plans to say" but was concerned enough to be here
"our current state history standards are strong" and she reviews how
"deeply concerning"
"resist any effort to rethink those" standards
"resist efforts to weaponize antisemitism"

Lawrence High grad Dario Guerrero (class of 2017); also Babson College grad
lack of resources provided to students like him
"education is an opportunity to progress in one's life"
MyCAP as opportunity to prepare students for college
mentorship and guidance for students

panel of other administrators on literacy regulations representing MASS
disagree with two year waiver proposed and narrow waiver, forcing districts to abandon curriculum review cycle
significant burden on elementary teachers on adoption of new curriculum
adoption of new curriculum takes YEARS
urge DESE to abandon waiver language of two years and narrow waiver
concerned about state literacy timeline
cannot adopt it without seeing it, cannot adopt it without a local curriculum review
"for an expedited and arbitrary timeline"
"must be done well and in collaboration with" local
ask strongly consider that 94% of districts that reported have already adopted curriculum that is "science of reading" and over 80% have recently reviewed
disagree with '27-28 implementation; DESE curriculum is not complete and only a portion will be created by that deadline
K-3 curriculum is a problem, as single K-5 curriculum is usual
"implementation of curriculum takes years, not months"
more than half of $200,000 on adoption
"forcing abrupt shifts"
"conflicts with how districts actually operate"

Aaron Polansky, president of MASS
"beliefs inform expectations"
share beliefs on what students deserve, high expecations
"our challenge is in the systems that are being used to implement them"
separation of implementors from those putting forward ideas
"meaningful collaboration much earlier in the process"
"a product does not transform a classroom; people do"
"when we reduce educational improvements to data points...we risk losing sight of the people"
"increasingly feel like they are drinking from a fire hose"
"we cannot claim to value educators" if we don't include what they are telling us

Anne Spitz, on inclusion of students with disabilities in literacy
how the literacy act can include blind and low-vision students
curriculum must include their needs and their teachers

Jessica Tang, AFT MA president
funding constraints that too many of districts are still facing
"what we need is a sustainable predicable state funding framework...including the true costs of inflation"
"need is urgent" 
costs don't operate on a per-student model
"ringing the alarm bells" that the federal terror campaign is having on our students
"ICE agents are continuing to act as if the law does not apply for them"
parent detained walking children to school
consistent regulations on protocols on what to do
report ICE at public schools dedicated line
student records and personal information protected
all families with information regarding their rights

Erin Cooley, Voices for Academic Equity Coalition
report yesterday
73% of districts set passing 65% of below
no common measure of mastery; "grades, which are increasingly inflated"
"diplomas and learning are diverging" (they're using 10th grade MCAS scores as if they're valid here)
"this is a system problem with no floor"
"set a statewide minimum passing score that indicates mastery which you can do now without legislation"
hmmm
standard end-of-course exam

Amanda Seider of One Goal on K-12 graduation council
importance and urgency of post-secondary planning
students average 38 minutes with a counselor
when they have more, they persist
AND WHERE IS THE MONEY FOR THESE COUNSELORS COMING FROM???
"the answer is not as simple as more counselors alone...reimagining high school"
I have yet to see a "reimagining" that didn't mean that teachers and other staff didn't simply end up with more work that they didn't "reimagine"

Vice Chair Matt Hills commenting on regulations on translation
"I have always felt a little more cautious about that" (translation)
"if it's a low level priority...use Google translation"
"since we passed a regulation, if you look at it and you think there are any modifications...I totally support it, or if you don't"
sensitive to how I use tools "that aren't high consequence" (so not an IEP)

Craven: Holocaust and Genocide Board Committee
Legislative committee recommended that the Board establish such a committee
reads some of the findings (note that there were concerns about this report when it was issued)
recommendation was curriculum, teaching training "to create intellectual diverse classroom"
Board committee to assess trust funding; to ensure that age-appropriate curriculum and resources
2018 DESE published curricula; not being proposed as a change today or anytime in the future
establish committee to do these two things
Craven, Hills, Mohamed to be on this committee

Zrike: thanks Lawrence for hosting
as superintendent learned a great deal from Lawrence
reflect on some items that are on the agenda
four goals tightly aligned and advance the Governor's priorities
statewide graudation standards, implement literacy act, 
"urgency we all should feel on stagnate academic outcomes...uneven graduation standards"
list of literacy curriculum released today
adoption of curriculum a complicated process; many have made decisions
"thoughtful process" locally
"if materials selected by districts made in good faith...respect decisions...committed to work with districts on a case-by-case basis"
"pledge to do in partnership with districts, not to districts"
it is odd that this is coming from the Secretary, not the Commissioner, as this would actually be he not the Secretary
MassCore and MyCAP one aspect from graduation report "but an important one"
no silver bullet
academic preparation students receive in high school does matter
highlight rural school districts gathering
teacher of the year recognition

Martinez: 
meeting with rural leaders, look at rural needs both previous and updated
recognizing districts for Seal of Biliteracy, getting equitable access, elevating culture and language
recognize assets of biliteracy
teacher apprenticeship
was at joint conference; "see a real desire to want to partner, to change the trajectory of our state"
Accountability status: keeping status the same "didn't see the progress we wanted to see"
"targeted supports not just for these schools but a larger piece"
literacy legislation "one of the most consequential" (it is not)
regulations out for public comment
"we have a lot of empathy for the field"
"sense of urgency...sense of frustration from the Legislation"
DESE publish list of K-3 curricula
"healthy tension...put out a list that is high-quality...but as soon as possible"
MASS survey "was done before we released the list"
curricula adopted in past few years that are 'slightly below'
"our publishers are responding" I cannot even; slap another sticker on that one!
"still approved and can be on that curriculum"
"doesn't even get reviewed unless it goes through a couple of national screeners" some of which have been discredited
I am looking for this list but I am not finding it online...
Hills: 
Martinez: before the law, no requirement that districts tell state what curricula they were using
it is odd to me that he thinks this is surprising
Craven: the Board has said that we'd like to see a comprehensive process with very few waivers
clarify that a district that bought what DESE said was high quality a few years ago and now they're locked in are we not seeing how ridiculous that is?
Martinez: "I believe the majority of districts are going to be okay"
Craven: "it begs the question did the science change the past few years...we don't want to seem capricious"
Martinez: transitional approvals "high quality but there is a higher quality"
Craven: in some cases, we are the source of the B and the A list
districts that relied upon DESE's list, and now DESE's list has changed
Martinez: new curriculum "has to be from the A and A-list"
Smidy: making sure that districts are very aware of how they can be supported if they've selected a curriculum from CURATE
Craven: are we listing what isn't fully passing muster
Martinez: "very transparent" "shared on our website"
"think it's a great thing; the urgency is there"
he keeps saying that it's great that "the publishers" are paying attention; publishers are paying attention because THEY MAKE MONEY WHEN THE STATE DOES THIS




No comments: