Monday, March 14, 2011

Detroit...Good news/bad news

Insightful article on the good news and bad news around the Detroit Public Schools. The good news?

The school, surrounded by vacant lots and abandoned houses, serves some of the city’s poorest children. Thieves who broke into the school last year escaped by disappearing into what the police call “the woods” — the blocks and blocks of vacant houses.

Yet Carstens students perform well on state tests, repeatedly meeting the federal standard for adequate yearly progress.
“We try to fill in the holes in our children’s lives,” said Rebecca Kelly-Gavrilovich, a Carstens teacher with 25 years’ experience. Students get free breakfast, lunch and — if they attend the after-school program — dinner.
To have more money for instruction, teachers sit with students at lunch, saving the school from having to hire lunchroom aides. Teachers hold jacket and shoe drives for children who have no winter coats and come to school in slippers. At Thanksgiving every child goes home with a frozen turkey donated by a local businessman. Twice a year a bus carrying a portable dentist’s office arrives, and a clinic is set up at the school so children can get their teeth checked.

But this is Detroit. Detroit is run by the financial manager Robert Bobb, and so on to the bad news:
Mr. Bobb has set off a vicious cycle undermining even good schools. The more schools he closes to save money, the more parents grow discouraged and pull their children out. The fewer the children, the less the state aid, so Mr. Bobb closes more schools.


Carstens has also been harmed by poor personnel decisions made by the district. Last year, 1,200 teachers took the retirement buyout, and Mr. Bobb laid off 2,000 others in the spring. Then in the fall, he realized he needed to hire the 2,000 back, and chaos ensued.


Two things to mention about Bobb: he was brought in as a business-oriented expert (he's Broad-trained). Also, this is the sort of system that is on the road to being allowed statewide in Michigan due to the new law passed by their Legislature: the all-powerful emergency financial manager, answerable only to the Governor.

1 comment:

Jim Gonyea said...

I'm sure OCP will come in and make things right.