Tuesday, April 7, 2015

more to read on the Atlanta verdict

You've no doubt caught that 11 of 12 Atlanta teachers and administrators were found guilty on various charges--mostly rackteering--around the cheating scandal. Note that the superintendent involved, Beverley Hall, died of cancer last month. Those found guilty, with the exception of one woman due to deliver a baby shortly, were immediately taken into custody.
Also note that larger questions of why teachers might find themselves in such a situation largely have not been part of the national conversation (possibly except for this New Yorker story from last July).

There's a whole lot going on here, so I'd recommend P.L. Thomas on the burden of the impossible, Jason Linkins about accountability in America, Richard Rothstein (likewise) on accountability but also numbers, Nancy Flanagan on power and control in test-cheating scandals, and José Vilson who pulls the identities of the teachers into the larger conversation around what our schools are facing.

DFER connection to No Boston Olympics

Nice catch by the Mass Political Profs bloggers on the DFER connection to No Boston Olympics (and a similar attitude towards funding transparency!)

Second Annenberg report on black and Latino males in Boston Public Schools

In a report that's being released tonight (5:30 at the BPS new Bolling building in Roxbury), the Annenberg Foundation, working in cooperation with the Center for Collaborative Education, found that:
“Scholars suggest that being explicit about the impact of racism in schools and society and developing an antiracist school culture in which people of color feel a sense of belonging and empowerment will lead to better outcomes for students of color,” the report said. “In contrast to this wisdom, the predominant mindset about race and gender in the case study schools was one of invisibility.”
You can read the Globe on this here.
The study was commissioned by BPS under Superintendent Carol Johnson in 2013, and this is actually the second phase of the report. This phase was intended to report on (as the title suggests) practices that were working, but the researcher struggled to find ones. Instead, they more deeply explored where the schools and students are at now.
For an introduction to critical race theory, see, for example, Delgado and Stefancic 

The pressures around small school districts in Vermont

Really interesting reading today from Vermont Public Radio on the pressures around small school districts in Vermont

Monday, April 6, 2015

Worcester School Committee meets Thursday

The Worcester School Committee has the first April meeting this Thursday, April 8 at 7pm. You can find the agenda here.

There are two things that may well be of general or continuing interest:


  • We are (finally) scheduled to set FY16 budgetary priorities. We were required to submit our ranked list last week; that has been shared with the committee members, and we'll be discussing this at the meeting. The budget comes out May 8.
  • We also have an facilities update on the Advanced Academy. It looks as though Doherty does not currently have room for it.



  • We are starting off the meeting with recognitions, and we have a TLSS subcommittee report to accept. We also have some personnel reports to accept.
    We have reports coming back on Read Across America day, on the Spring into Books book drive, and on internal v public documents.
    It's time to elect a delegate and an alternate to the MASC annual meeting.
    Mr. Monfredo asks if the testing calendar changed as a result of snow days (the response is we extended the window).
    Miss Biancheria is looking for an expert to talk about linking cameras to the police department, and also about budgetary means for additional positions at North. Also, she's interested in what training is giving to staff regarding electronic media use.
    Mr. Monfredo would like to recognize our facilities staff for their fine work this winter. He'd also like to set a date in October to meet with our delegation, and to encourage students to take part in the Worcester Bravehearts Home Run club (which I can't find anything about online).
    Mr. O'Connell would like to congratulation the Burncoat Green Reapers and the crew team.
    Mr. Monfredo wants to know if we can give preference to people who reside in Worcester in hiring (see MGL Ch. 71, sec. 38).
    We're being asked to declare as surplus a sliver of land directly next to Nelson Place School as part of the land swaps necessary to build the school. THIS IS NOT THE ASSUMPTION DEAL. This is essentially trading land with a neighbor to improve things for construction.
    WE'RE GETTING ANOTHER FOOD TRUCK!
    We're going to be considering summer reading and new courses in TLSS and considering the student handbook in Governance (those meetings and specifics to come).
    And we have an executive session to consider a grievance. 

    Thursday, April 2, 2015

    Stop reading press releases and start reading spreadsheets, Mr. Secretary

    You  may have caught that Mass Secretary of Education Peyser was on Greater Boston with Jim Braude earlier this week. WGBH has done us all the favor of posting a transcript of the conversation along with the video.
    While we all knew that we now have a Secretary of Education who has no experience in teaching, what is apparent from this conversation is we also have a Secretary of Education who has no interest? experience? knowledge? of or in school or budgetary operations, either.

    Braude asked: Do you have enough money to do what you think needs to be done to close that achievement gap that Democrats and Republicans want to close?
    Peyser responded: So I think we do have enough money.
    Then, after conceding that money matters, look what he uses as an example: 
     Using Lawrence as another example: The state went in there and basically did not spend a lot of new money but reallocated money out of the central office and put it back into the schools, and that’s the way in which we can go forward and get more out of what we’ve got.
    As I've posted previously, this is simply untrue. The year that the state put Lawrence into receivership, Lawrence was nearly $9 million under required spending. The next year, Lawrence was $1.3 million OVER required minimum spending. That swing of $10 million is certainly "a lot of new money."  There's no doubt it would make a difference on a budget of $155 million, which is where Lawrence started. 
    (And remember: you don't have to believe me; go download the Chapter 70 profile spreadsheet yourself.)
    Above, when responding to the question about enough money, the two numbers Peyser cites are the $100 million increase in state education aid and the $4.6 billion in state education aid total, both of which have been cited in about every press release I've seen on the budget. Those are, yes, both big numbers. They also are cited completely without any context.
    The context lacking is that of the various thoroughly researched reports that show the gap in funding, like MassBudget's Cutting Class. It is hardly news in Massachusetts that the settlement of the McDuffy suit is overdue for reconsideration, as it's undercalculated.
    This has also been the subject of hours and pages of testimony from districts across the state before the Foundation Budget Review Commission. Inflation, special education, and health insurance are drastically undercalcuated, and districts are either funding above foundation to cover it or cutting other areas--classroom areas--to cover it. The Secretary sits on that Commission. That he has missed the loud and clear message coming from districts makes it clear that his is an idealogical rather than thoughtful and researched position. 

    Wednesday, April 1, 2015

    TLSS meets today at 5:30

    The Teaching, Learning, and Student Supports committee meets today at 5:30 in the fourth floor conference room at DAB. You can find the agenda here.
    Items on service learning, an early warning system for dropouts, an expired bill on dress codes, and the Temporary Learning Center.
    I'm not going to be at that, but you can watch it live on Channel 11.