You can find the agenda here.
I'm not going to catch all of this, as I have to duck out to take a call, but notes going up here from the opening remarks by Monty Tech Superintendent Sheila Harrity, Chair Paul Sagan, Commissioner Chester, and Secretary of Education James Peyser.
Posting as we go...
Sagan notes that Craven and Doherty will not be able to attend.
Sagan: take opportunity to share some thoughts and perspective
"honot and prilege to serve on this Board...best to serve the families of this Commonwealth...proud tradition of public education"
"every child have a high quality education"
"continuum of stakeholders...to do even better than those who worked on these efforts before us"
"leave
"one top priority...child who come into our system and their families...all of the others come second...I don't think we're here in service to the adults"
"tremendous respect for teachers...need to support them and given them the chance to succeed at their difficult jobs"
most of the time his kids went to public school and most of the time in Massachusetts
"despite the statistics that we all get to see...too many of our schools are not succeeding for our kids...have to do for our kids"
schools are failing in their mission, determined to change that
"just look at those" on waiting list "for alternative public schools"
"anything short of responding to these families would be shameful"
moved to Massachusetts 17 years ago, cites experience working with charter school (MATCH)
"so here's the first lesson I took away from this...kids I had heard over and over again couldn't achieve at high levels" could
results again and again...cites CREDO study
"to do anything less for every other child" is inconceivable
"not here for poltics
public schools "in well-functioning districts and those we'll have to create with more autonomy"
from MATCH: exceptional teachers attract exceptional results
wife taught at MATCH, countless hours, calls at home
"She and her colleagues never gave up on their kids"
"support expansion of charter schools in many communities because I believe that is part of the answer"
not only that
"support additional excellence from new charter schools"
close those that don't
1993 Ed Reform, 2011 Act
"all measures open to us to turnaround underperforming schools and even disttricts"
"as much as possible work with districts...but not hesitation to intervene when" needed
important parallels with business: who we're serving and to what end
"our leadership comes from leadership on School Committees,...superintenedents...principals...teachers...and I look forward to their leadership and collaboration"
"move those folks along when they just aren't doing what they should be doing anymore"
make changes "with much greater urgency"
concern for each child, "and I'm not going to be patient about it"
"we've got a lot to do"
Chester: new study from Rennie Center on field trials of PARCC
will give copies of testimony to Ways and Means on education budgets
summary of actions under authority delegated
"great to be here at Monty Tech"
Peyser: have been a small ask while you were being asked (to Sagan)
thanks to Margaret McKenna: role is vitally important to the success of this board
Board meeting is halfway to Greenfield where the Ways and Means hearing is
Tuesday, March 24, 2015
Monday, March 23, 2015
Board update on teacher licensure
Chester: Board has a role here, sets regulation around licensure
"ultimately we'd like to make sure that our educators" are good at creating student learning
creating spaces "where students thrive" not only cognatively, but not least of all cognatively
"are our kids making good gains, year to year"
"what do we know about the kinds of classrooms that they're running"
measures of teacher credentials: transcripts, MTEL scores, courses taken
measures of teacher knowledge: the above plus National Board, value college degree, literacy
"want to know that you've got strong moral character"
starting point when we start to conceptionize
"how can we be as confident as possible throught the licensure" that we're creating environments in which youngsters thrive?
handoff to DESE staff
fit current schema under categories of evidence
Sagan asks how moral character is measured: CORI check, fingerprinting...is response
someone mentions that there's an affidavit as part of application
Sagan "not sure I'd call that moral character"
Roach: reference checks at district level
McKenna: really drill down on character at district level
back to presentation:
MTEL: literacy, subject knowledge, pedagogy
plus performance assessment done by program
for professional stage: three years under initial license; induction/mentoring; Master's degree
practice is a "latent statutory requirement"
McKenna asks about backlog on teacher licensure: "we busted the backlog" of licensure
Sagan: are we going to maintain that or are we going to have a budget problem? "Under my watch, Chairman Sagan, we do have a process"
"What sort of evidence should we ask for for these different categories" is what DESE is asking now
for renewal: professional licensure
higher numbers of preliminary licenses in areas that are high need (who have no ed prep programs)
McKenna: "how do we justify giving a license to someone who has no experience and no preparation in elementary school?"
response: how do we make sure that we have people who are ready to make impact on the first day?
looking at evidence on the table about what we're doing, what's working "and if the license is relevant"
pass rates data on disparate rates from those who are white and of color
actions taken by DESE as a result: communication and literacy skills test was redeveloped
improved transparency on technical qualities of test (have made reports available on the website)
statistical analysis to see if different test takers perform differently on different items
hey, anyone know if they do this on MCAS? Or will on PARCC?
"disturbing gap" among test takers in pass rates (and I have the chart which I will post later)
Short version; in 13-14 pass rate was:
"ultimately we'd like to make sure that our educators" are good at creating student learning
creating spaces "where students thrive" not only cognatively, but not least of all cognatively
"are our kids making good gains, year to year"
"what do we know about the kinds of classrooms that they're running"
measures of teacher credentials: transcripts, MTEL scores, courses taken
measures of teacher knowledge: the above plus National Board, value college degree, literacy
"want to know that you've got strong moral character"
starting point when we start to conceptionize
"how can we be as confident as possible throught the licensure" that we're creating environments in which youngsters thrive?
handoff to DESE staff
fit current schema under categories of evidence
Sagan asks how moral character is measured: CORI check, fingerprinting...is response
someone mentions that there's an affidavit as part of application
Sagan "not sure I'd call that moral character"
Roach: reference checks at district level
McKenna: really drill down on character at district level
back to presentation:
MTEL: literacy, subject knowledge, pedagogy
plus performance assessment done by program
for professional stage: three years under initial license; induction/mentoring; Master's degree
practice is a "latent statutory requirement"
McKenna asks about backlog on teacher licensure: "we busted the backlog" of licensure
Sagan: are we going to maintain that or are we going to have a budget problem? "Under my watch, Chairman Sagan, we do have a process"
"What sort of evidence should we ask for for these different categories" is what DESE is asking now
for renewal: professional licensure
higher numbers of preliminary licenses in areas that are high need (who have no ed prep programs)
McKenna: "how do we justify giving a license to someone who has no experience and no preparation in elementary school?"
response: how do we make sure that we have people who are ready to make impact on the first day?
looking at evidence on the table about what we're doing, what's working "and if the license is relevant"
pass rates data on disparate rates from those who are white and of color
actions taken by DESE as a result: communication and literacy skills test was redeveloped
improved transparency on technical qualities of test (have made reports available on the website)
statistical analysis to see if different test takers perform differently on different items
hey, anyone know if they do this on MCAS? Or will on PARCC?
"disturbing gap" among test takers in pass rates (and I have the chart which I will post later)
Short version; in 13-14 pass rate was:
- all 84%
- whites 85%
- blacks 59%
- Hispanic 73%
- Asian/ Pacific Islander 77%
and that bears out in subject matter tests, as well
note vast disparity in who is taking the test; within subject tests:
- 21,837 took tests over all
- of those 16,454 were white
- 705 were black
- 805 Hispanic
- 575 Asian/ Pacific Islander
Noyce asking where people are coming from and which are most successful: DESE doesn't have it offhand but will look
Willyard: how are we getting more people into teaching?
DESE; outreach and diverse candidates in programs; also highlighting how programs are helping candidates take and pass MTEL
Performance Assessment for Leaders (which they of course are abbreviating PAL) for principals
have to complete tasks this year, next year have to pass them
- set a vision for school improvement
- development a professional learning culture within a school
- observing, assessing, and supporting teacher effectiveness
- leadership for family engagement and community involvement
have heard "that it's very real and authentic" about what they will be asked to do
McKenna: back to item analysis
plan is to do annual analysis, yes
McKenna: has there ever been predictability in the test?
"not appropriate for licensure test, which is pass/fail test" not like SAT which is designed to predict performance
McKenna: except that I remember that your SAT can predict your MTEL
Sagan: asks if gender cut would make any difference
Have not done that analysis
Sagan "happy to see a test that lots of people fail, but don't want to see a test" that particular groups are failing out of proportion
Chester: can be much more ambitious
Board of Ed overview of Governor's budget
I've got a few alarming notes to share on this, first, from DESE's memo to the Board, which I've sent out to Worcester and the statewide School Committees:
- regarding chapter 70, the two things touted are "a minimum aid increase for each district of $20 per student" and "continuing progress to achieving equity in high-effort communities"
- regarding the elimination of Quality K: "recognizing that more than 85% of districts offer full day Kindergarten and that enrollment is reimbursed through Chapter 70"
- regarding the grant merger: "a broader approach to improving outcomes for students...is designed to provide the Department with the authority to exercise discretion and innovative approaches to combat systemic underperformance"
- regarding student assessment: the $28.9M "provides the funding necessary to manage the potential transition of PARCC"
- regarding aligned programs (this is school-to-work, AP math & science, expanded learning time, and after school grants): they "include the authorization to allow ESE to use a portion of these resources to align with the work of the Partnership Schools Network initiative
And, on to the notes at the Board; I didn't catch who is doing this presentation:
"through the recommendations this Board made to the Secretary last November"
'though I was at that meeting and I'd dispute that this is the Board's priorities
spending level with the consistent with spending this year
chapter 70 pretty much given
$20/pupil minimum aid, effort reduction 45% factor both contribute to $105M
licensing effective educators
"to look at our grant programs from the perspective of leveraging effectiveness"
traditional targeted assistance program with a number of other grants
"discretion to the Commissioner" to work with those districts in a number of ways
PARCC transitional assessement program
educator effectiveness work
dollars for student safety work
Fy16 "transitional year for us" due to the end of Race to the Top
"primarilally funded" by federal funds
federal grant funding "not looking robust"
"we're excited about the Governor's budget in a number of ways, actually"
Peyser: chapter 70 "a core priority"
"nonetheless is a lot of money in terms of the incremental resources that were available to allocate overall"
"concentrate resources into a pool of flexible funds to invest strategically in order to drive" change
"it's not clear that they're moving the needle on student performance"
"concentrate resources" to make "meaningful change"
"that was the thesis behind the budget"
"savings that were achieved in the budget": full day K
initiated in 1990's when 30% or less had full day K; now more than 90% have full day K
"intended to be primary funding vehicle" of full day K
"has been tremendously successful"
"not that it won't cause tremendously dislocating to local communities"
Willyard: $50M that we're losing: where and what programs are going to be eliminated?
RTTT loss: fundamentally is work that with those funds we've achieved what we've looked to do
Commissioner: like the consolidation around the Partnership Schools Network
"very, very imporant investments that I hope the Legislature will stick to"
concerned with state oversight: not just RTTT
Race to the Top "allowed us to be much more deliberative as a state agency"
"going to be challenging for us" is early retirement incentive
Roach: when is it gone? June 30
Chester: half of the $50M is distributed to local school districts...a lot smaller amount that we're relying on
Roach: "is it going to be a challenge for you? I can't imagine you have as many folks on deck as this plays out"
Chester: general curriculum support "will be hardest hit" from RTTT loss
Calderon-Rosado: monitoring school districts and progress across the state
Chester: substantially more potential support for accountability and turnaround work
"in that respect, it's very exciting"
Noyce: will we see some high need districts seeing loss of funds as result of not being able to write compelling grants?
Peyser: idea is not to spread money around to everyone who may have strong need, but places "where they have both strong need and sustantial cases for improvement"
"how do we manage that transition" this year
"may be some further work we have to do in the course of this coming in the hopes that when we get into FY17 we may have a substantial backlog"
"I don't think it would be entirely bad if we said 'no' to a number of districts this year" as we set the bar high
Chester argues that this is an extension of turnaround grants, RTTT, etc
Roach: how does it compare to current funding of grants? $5M less
"we're short five as a practical matter"
Just please make sure you read the comments above. And then get in touch with your legislators.
"we're excited about the Governor's budget in a number of ways, actually"
Peyser: chapter 70 "a core priority"
"nonetheless is a lot of money in terms of the incremental resources that were available to allocate overall"
"concentrate resources into a pool of flexible funds to invest strategically in order to drive" change
"it's not clear that they're moving the needle on student performance"
"concentrate resources" to make "meaningful change"
"that was the thesis behind the budget"
"savings that were achieved in the budget": full day K
initiated in 1990's when 30% or less had full day K; now more than 90% have full day K
"intended to be primary funding vehicle" of full day K
"has been tremendously successful"
"not that it won't cause tremendously dislocating to local communities"
Willyard: $50M that we're losing: where and what programs are going to be eliminated?
RTTT loss: fundamentally is work that with those funds we've achieved what we've looked to do
Commissioner: like the consolidation around the Partnership Schools Network
"very, very imporant investments that I hope the Legislature will stick to"
concerned with state oversight: not just RTTT
Race to the Top "allowed us to be much more deliberative as a state agency"
"going to be challenging for us" is early retirement incentive
Roach: when is it gone? June 30
Chester: half of the $50M is distributed to local school districts...a lot smaller amount that we're relying on
Roach: "is it going to be a challenge for you? I can't imagine you have as many folks on deck as this plays out"
Chester: general curriculum support "will be hardest hit" from RTTT loss
Calderon-Rosado: monitoring school districts and progress across the state
Chester: substantially more potential support for accountability and turnaround work
"in that respect, it's very exciting"
Noyce: will we see some high need districts seeing loss of funds as result of not being able to write compelling grants?
Peyser: idea is not to spread money around to everyone who may have strong need, but places "where they have both strong need and sustantial cases for improvement"
"how do we manage that transition" this year
"may be some further work we have to do in the course of this coming in the hopes that when we get into FY17 we may have a substantial backlog"
"I don't think it would be entirely bad if we said 'no' to a number of districts this year" as we set the bar high
Chester argues that this is an extension of turnaround grants, RTTT, etc
Roach: how does it compare to current funding of grants? $5M less
"we're short five as a practical matter"
Just please make sure you read the comments above. And then get in touch with your legislators.
Board of Ed briefing on Chapter 70 and the Foundation Budget
the PowerPoint does not appear to be online; posting as we go
Chester: to put Chapter 70 in a context of all funding that comes to public education in the Commonwealth
"we are a $16 1/2B endeavour...Chapter 70 is one component...majority of funds come from local revenue sources
turns it over to Wulfson
"not planning to go into all of the details" of Chapter 70 funding
$5,788B is local contribution and $4,301B is chapter 70
$1604B is local contribution ABOVE NSS
prior to 1993, school budgets determined locally with no minimun spending requirements from the state
per pupil spending varied widely in relation to the wealth of the community
"cherish...the public schools" not just aspirational
1993 Ed Reform "grand bargain"
nearly $2B increase in state aid: school committees retain budgetary discretion, staffing reforms, accountability system, charter schools and interdistrict school choice
to ensure that every district has sufficient resources to provide and adequate educational program, through an equitable combination of local and state funds
"at a high level, it's fairly easy to understand"
foundation budget, determination of local ability to contribution, remainder is state aid
foundation budget rates differ by category
Sagan interrupts to confirms that this sets a minimum; it does
asks for high need special education: Wulfson explains the purposeful undercalculating of special ed and the circuit breaker reimbursement
1997: target local share based on property values and resident incomes
"designed to be a progressive formula"
FBRC: has held six meetings, report due June 30
formula has not been majorly revised...ever, really
districts can and do spend more than foundation
"a clue that some foundation budget categories may be lagging behind here today"
Peyser asks about underfunding: Wulfson 95% carryover
are there some that are perpetually at the under? Yes, Wulfson
Willyard: if we're cutting funding for schools that don't fund fully, how does cutting aid help?
Wulfson: gets the attention of the appropriating authority
Roach: asks if anyone is going to these meetings? Yes. how much is local appropriation coming up?
Hatch: has come up but note that Chairs have noted that it is outside the purview of the commission
"people are not universally pleased, but mainly they are"
(uh, wow...okay...)
Hatch "by my calculation we're about $2B off on funding" statewide
"comments we've received have been generally positive"
Wulfson: cost drivers of out-of-district sped, health insurance, extended learning time (?)
notes Governor's call to move extended day out of grants and into Chapter 70
"very little corralation between" test scores and spending level
Sagan: "since this student growth, you could be very very high and see little growth"
Wulfson "when you see absolute achievement, it tends to correlate with socio-economic status"
McKenna: why is Boston's aid so low?
Wulfson: Boston's a very wealthy community; "has a lot of fiscal capacity compared to other urban areas"
Hatch: target is minimum state aid, "is receiving about 30% of its aid"
"the fact that it's getting 30% of its aid is function of the formula prior to this one"
does suprise people, foundation budget does reflect student population that it has
Hatch now reviewing aggregate wealth
Wulfson: are hearing that communities are finding it hard to keep up with funding increases under Prop 2 1/2
Willyard: set rate where the state determines who each student is worth?
Yes. and charter is the same? Yes.
and came from where: hypothetical budget based on actual costs (back in 93), raised by the inflation factor each year
Chester: sorting through funding of low income ELL students here
Wulfson: intended to pay for longer school days, longer classes
Chester: recognition that districts may have to go extra mile
no monitoring that those dollars are going to funding those children
Wulfson: in fairness to districts, increases in special ed and health care, "we'd have a lot more money to restore to the classroom"
Sagan: "regardless of the district in question, dollars follow child to charter school"
Wulfson: three components to charter school: foundation level, plus over NSS amount (by district), facilities aid to charters in lieu of MSBA
Sagan: charter reimbursement in any year?
Wulfson: increase in tuition in any given year in total
Doherty: special ed: does it vary by moderate or severe?
Wulfson: no
Hatch: points out that many have complained about rates and amounts
"but the fact is...the initial assumption was 14% of the kids would be in special ed 25% of the time...full time equivalency, not a head count"
has been one of the most consistent complaints "by people who don't quite get that point"
Peyser: inflation factor has run?
Hatch: 1.5, this year, fairly typical
Wulfson: doesn't track with CPI, but goes up and down
Peyser: do you think that covers the health insurance?
Wulfson: "that's one of the mysteries"
Peyser quips that if it does, he wants to know what they're buying
Peyser: tracking with aggregate wealth?
Wulfson: increase in local contribution keeping up with foundation budget (statewide)
Peyser fleshing out degree to which changes in inflation change dollar amount statewide
Wulfson: "can come down" within range
most years Legislature has chosen to hold harmless or have a net increase
"never go beyond foundation, but play around with above or at foundation"
Chester: to put Chapter 70 in a context of all funding that comes to public education in the Commonwealth
"we are a $16 1/2B endeavour...Chapter 70 is one component...majority of funds come from local revenue sources
turns it over to Wulfson
"not planning to go into all of the details" of Chapter 70 funding
$5,788B is local contribution and $4,301B is chapter 70
$1604B is local contribution ABOVE NSS
prior to 1993, school budgets determined locally with no minimun spending requirements from the state
per pupil spending varied widely in relation to the wealth of the community
"cherish...the public schools" not just aspirational
1993 Ed Reform "grand bargain"
nearly $2B increase in state aid: school committees retain budgetary discretion, staffing reforms, accountability system, charter schools and interdistrict school choice
to ensure that every district has sufficient resources to provide and adequate educational program, through an equitable combination of local and state funds
"at a high level, it's fairly easy to understand"
foundation budget, determination of local ability to contribution, remainder is state aid
foundation budget rates differ by category
Sagan interrupts to confirms that this sets a minimum; it does
asks for high need special education: Wulfson explains the purposeful undercalculating of special ed and the circuit breaker reimbursement
1997: target local share based on property values and resident incomes
"designed to be a progressive formula"
FBRC: has held six meetings, report due June 30
formula has not been majorly revised...ever, really
districts can and do spend more than foundation
"a clue that some foundation budget categories may be lagging behind here today"
Peyser asks about underfunding: Wulfson 95% carryover
are there some that are perpetually at the under? Yes, Wulfson
Willyard: if we're cutting funding for schools that don't fund fully, how does cutting aid help?
Wulfson: gets the attention of the appropriating authority
Roach: asks if anyone is going to these meetings? Yes. how much is local appropriation coming up?
Hatch: has come up but note that Chairs have noted that it is outside the purview of the commission
"people are not universally pleased, but mainly they are"
(uh, wow...okay...)
Hatch "by my calculation we're about $2B off on funding" statewide
"comments we've received have been generally positive"
Wulfson: cost drivers of out-of-district sped, health insurance, extended learning time (?)
notes Governor's call to move extended day out of grants and into Chapter 70
"very little corralation between" test scores and spending level
Sagan: "since this student growth, you could be very very high and see little growth"
Wulfson "when you see absolute achievement, it tends to correlate with socio-economic status"
McKenna: why is Boston's aid so low?
Wulfson: Boston's a very wealthy community; "has a lot of fiscal capacity compared to other urban areas"
Hatch: target is minimum state aid, "is receiving about 30% of its aid"
"the fact that it's getting 30% of its aid is function of the formula prior to this one"
does suprise people, foundation budget does reflect student population that it has
Hatch now reviewing aggregate wealth
Wulfson: are hearing that communities are finding it hard to keep up with funding increases under Prop 2 1/2
Willyard: set rate where the state determines who each student is worth?
Yes. and charter is the same? Yes.
and came from where: hypothetical budget based on actual costs (back in 93), raised by the inflation factor each year
Chester: sorting through funding of low income ELL students here
Wulfson: intended to pay for longer school days, longer classes
Chester: recognition that districts may have to go extra mile
no monitoring that those dollars are going to funding those children
Wulfson: in fairness to districts, increases in special ed and health care, "we'd have a lot more money to restore to the classroom"
Sagan: "regardless of the district in question, dollars follow child to charter school"
Wulfson: three components to charter school: foundation level, plus over NSS amount (by district), facilities aid to charters in lieu of MSBA
Sagan: charter reimbursement in any year?
Wulfson: increase in tuition in any given year in total
Doherty: special ed: does it vary by moderate or severe?
Wulfson: no
Hatch: points out that many have complained about rates and amounts
"but the fact is...the initial assumption was 14% of the kids would be in special ed 25% of the time...full time equivalency, not a head count"
has been one of the most consistent complaints "by people who don't quite get that point"
Peyser: inflation factor has run?
Hatch: 1.5, this year, fairly typical
Wulfson: doesn't track with CPI, but goes up and down
Peyser: do you think that covers the health insurance?
Wulfson: "that's one of the mysteries"
Peyser quips that if it does, he wants to know what they're buying
Peyser: tracking with aggregate wealth?
Wulfson: increase in local contribution keeping up with foundation budget (statewide)
Peyser fleshing out degree to which changes in inflation change dollar amount statewide
Wulfson: "can come down" within range
most years Legislature has chosen to hold harmless or have a net increase
"never go beyond foundation, but play around with above or at foundation"
From the Monday evening edition of the Board of Ed
As you might know, the Mass Board of Ed has this somewhat odd meeting schedule: they have a Monday evening meeting, generally just for discussion, followed by a Tuesday morning meeting, where the votes happen. You can find the full agenda for March here. This month, the evening meeting is in Malden, and the Tuesday morning meeting is in Fitchburg.
I largely came due to the Chapter 70/Foundation Budget Review Commission discussion, but I'll post as I have anything.
I largely came due to the Chapter 70/Foundation Budget Review Commission discussion, but I'll post as I have anything.
We're doing what with Nelson Place land?
This was originally an adendum to the announcement of a public meeting on Nelson Place next Monday the 30th, but at this point, I'm concerned enough that I'm giving it its own post.
Item 9.6B regarding Nelson Place on the Council agenda for Tuesday is a land swap with Assumption that appears to give Assumption access around a wetland to the back edge of their property. Note, per Commissioner Moosey's memo, that the City already had the easement it needed for building a new Nelson Place through an early February vote of the City Council. This change simply benefits Assumption through the land swap. This assessor's map may clear things up a bit: Assumption owns 12 Romula (at the bottom right, which gives access onto a road) and owns the property marked as 0 behind that and the property marked as 500 (it's 500 Salisbury, their main campus) on the left middle of the map. You'll note that the property marked 0 and 500 Salisbury don't connect, but they could get from one to other via WPS property by cutting the corner of Nelson Place (which is 35, for 35 Nelson Place, in upper right).
This seems to involve a land easement swap of WPS land as voted by the City Council, which it can't legally do; as we all have become very clear on, WPS land and the rights to it can only be conveyed through a majority School Committee vote.
Moreover, an easement across public land, as it's a public asset that is being offered, would need to go out to bid. This hasn't.
And the land in question is on the Open Space Top Ten List as passed by the Worcester City Council; it's called Bald Hill.
There was an effort at the very beginning of the Nelson Place process to try to tie this to new fields at the top of the hill that Assumption would pay for and allow the public to use...in fact, it sounded a lot like the deal that was being offered with Worcester State about fields adjoining Jesse Burkett field. The Worcester Public Schools administration made it VERY clear that this was not of interest; this is a school project, and playing field projects for public use and the college ties that may or may not go with them was not part of the deal (and, frankly, is a level of complication we'd just as soon not have).
This neighborhood has likewise been very concerned about Assumption's role, if any, in all of this, as they're concerned about Assumption's expansion and ongoing questions around transparency.
I've been impressed at how this has been handled by both administrations (most notably by Julie Lynch, who works for the DPW and has been the point person for the Nelson Place project). This deal undermines all of that.
I don't have an answer to any of this as yet. Yes, I've been chasing this down, but if it concerns you, I'd let Council know before Tuesday night.
Item 9.6B regarding Nelson Place on the Council agenda for Tuesday is a land swap with Assumption that appears to give Assumption access around a wetland to the back edge of their property. Note, per Commissioner Moosey's memo, that the City already had the easement it needed for building a new Nelson Place through an early February vote of the City Council. This change simply benefits Assumption through the land swap. This assessor's map may clear things up a bit: Assumption owns 12 Romula (at the bottom right, which gives access onto a road) and owns the property marked as 0 behind that and the property marked as 500 (it's 500 Salisbury, their main campus) on the left middle of the map. You'll note that the property marked 0 and 500 Salisbury don't connect, but they could get from one to other via WPS property by cutting the corner of Nelson Place (which is 35, for 35 Nelson Place, in upper right).
This seems to involve a land easement swap of WPS land as voted by the City Council, which it can't legally do; as we all have become very clear on, WPS land and the rights to it can only be conveyed through a majority School Committee vote.
Moreover, an easement across public land, as it's a public asset that is being offered, would need to go out to bid. This hasn't.
And the land in question is on the Open Space Top Ten List as passed by the Worcester City Council; it's called Bald Hill.
There was an effort at the very beginning of the Nelson Place process to try to tie this to new fields at the top of the hill that Assumption would pay for and allow the public to use...in fact, it sounded a lot like the deal that was being offered with Worcester State about fields adjoining Jesse Burkett field. The Worcester Public Schools administration made it VERY clear that this was not of interest; this is a school project, and playing field projects for public use and the college ties that may or may not go with them was not part of the deal (and, frankly, is a level of complication we'd just as soon not have).
This neighborhood has likewise been very concerned about Assumption's role, if any, in all of this, as they're concerned about Assumption's expansion and ongoing questions around transparency.
I've been impressed at how this has been handled by both administrations (most notably by Julie Lynch, who works for the DPW and has been the point person for the Nelson Place project). This deal undermines all of that.
I don't have an answer to any of this as yet. Yes, I've been chasing this down, but if it concerns you, I'd let Council know before Tuesday night.
Sunday, March 22, 2015
Boston's shrinking school-aged population, community, and funding the education of other people's children
Commonwealth this week tackles the issue of Boston's shrinking school-aged population--at its peak, it may well have been 200,000 or more, and now is 100,000 or so--and the impact that has on the city as a whole:
This came to mind as I read the PBS Newshour interview with Robert Putnam about his new book Our Kids. I think that it's difficult to draw any conclusions "apart from racism and homophobia," but I think the question of who "our kids" are is exactly the right question to be asking. Putnam says:
The conclusion he draws, however, is absolutely correct:
As for Boston, the city is responsible for funding a bit over 80% of its foundation budget, due to the city's significant community wealth. Yet the city argues every year that the school budget must be cut. Mobilizing that community wealth to do better by its school children (40% Latino and 33% Black) is a key part of the question of how to bring back a full community, including children, to the streets of Boston.
And for all of us, it means we need to prioritize the needs of all kids, regardless of how much they look like those of us making the decisions.
What is troubling to us, however, is that as a result of these demographic changes, Boston is becoming not only a city without young people to shovel snow for those of us with arthritic hands and bad backs, but also a city which has a strikingly reduced number of young people participating in Little League, youth hockey, scout groups, and all of those other bedrock institutions that cement neighborhoods and create a sense of community.
Harvard political scientist Robert Putnam, author of Bowling Alone, and others have written extensively about such phenomena. Sadly, although it is difficult for the census to track this, we know that in neighborhoods across the city, among people from certain socioeconomic backgrounds, there is a robust interest in living in the city until a family’s oldest child is ready for school, at which point the decision is made to seek alternatives to public school, or, most likely, move out of the city.They close by asking: Shouldn’t a great city also do whatever it can to be more welcoming to families with children?
This came to mind as I read the PBS Newshour interview with Robert Putnam about his new book Our Kids. I think that it's difficult to draw any conclusions "apart from racism and homophobia," but I think the question of who "our kids" are is exactly the right question to be asking. Putnam says:
When I was growing up in Port Clinton 50 years ago, my parents talked about, “We’ve got to do things for our kids. We’ve got to pay higher taxes so our kids can have a better swimming pool, or we’ve got to pay higher taxes so we can have a new French department in school,” or whatever. When they said that, they did not just mean my sister and me — it was all the kids here in town, of all sorts. But what’s happened, and this is sort of the bowling alone story, is that over this last 30, 40, 50 years, the meaning of “our kids” has narrowed and narrowed and narrowed so that now when people say, “We’ve got to do something for our kids,” they mean MY biological kids.I haven't yet read Putnam's book, so I don't know how he tackles how this issue interacts with race, in particular. I'm not as sure that "our kids" necessarily ever included "kids that don't look like mine." It wasn't, for example, 50 but 40 years ago that the Boston School Committee was sued over educational equity issues and a majority of them were willing to go to jail rather than accept the federal court-ordered desegregation.
The conclusion he draws, however, is absolutely correct:
The evidence suggests that when in American history we’ve invested more in the education of less well-off kids, it’s been good for everybody. My grandchildren are going to pay a huge price in their adult life because there’s a bunch of other kids, in principle just as productive as them, who didn’t get investments from their family and community, and therefore are not productive citizens. The best economic estimates are that the costs to everybody, including my own grandchildren, of not investing in those “other people’s kids” are going to be very high.As the public school population this past year became majority children of color in a country that is still majority white as a whole, that means that we're going to need adults across the board to invest in children who may not look like them.
As for Boston, the city is responsible for funding a bit over 80% of its foundation budget, due to the city's significant community wealth. Yet the city argues every year that the school budget must be cut. Mobilizing that community wealth to do better by its school children (40% Latino and 33% Black) is a key part of the question of how to bring back a full community, including children, to the streets of Boston.
And for all of us, it means we need to prioritize the needs of all kids, regardless of how much they look like those of us making the decisions.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)