Tuesday, November 15, 2022

Notes from the Board of Ed: FY24 budget

the back up is here

Mohamed: most of the budget is already earmarked (the bulk of it Ch. 70)
discussed several priorities:
early grade literacy
work on curriculum review and recommended best practices
career and technical education
multitiered systems of support
touched on issue of gifted and talented education
"budget committee is not a policy-making committee"
better for that discussion to happen with this board

Moriarty: let us present some good ideas that others want to think about on gifted and talented
"important and worthy topic"

Plankey: forwarding ideas on to legislators and policy makers
would like to see ideas explored more thoroughly
can be overlap in some of commissioner's goals, with getting education that's personally engaging 

Hills: policy should be driving the budget
those have to start with the Department
"there's been a lot of other stuff going on the past few years and I'm aware of it"
"everything that is a priority doesn't get done"

Stewart: still haven't had a conversation at the Board on gifted and talented

roll call on FY24 recommendations passes, which Bill Bell notes will go to "gubernatorial-elect Healey and her team"

Notes from the November Board of Ed: family engagement

 report from the family engagement summit
Riley: "parents are more than ready to be involved...they are the sleeping giant in education"
Deputy Commissioner Robinson whose opening comments we entirely missed as we couldn't hear them

"vision casting"
every registration had to have families registered
"families were so encouraged to have the Commissioner present"
Rachelle Engler Bennett (Associate Commissioner): work to strengthen work in this realm
Department developed a cross-agency framework
Office of student and family support: team of 20 supports
Olga Lopez, Family Engagement Specialist
summit had 400 participants; 37 workshops offered; 29 districts participated

Mary Stewart "family engagement...is a strategy for school improvement, it's a strategy for student success"
"communication isn't the only thing" as how parents parent also matters
"incredibly positive experience"

Robinson: all gathered together, focused on student success
Stewart: practitioners to get that experience of having that with families; to share power with families

Hills: what do you want to see a year from now?
Lopez: families engagement, sitting down together, not afraid to share their ideas

Mohamed: what does access look like?
Lopez: different initiatives, outreach coordinators reaching different families
train a trainers, teach school districts how to engage with families

Canavan: communication and access
school council meetings during the workday: I had some flexibility but not everybody does
how do we share information and how to do we create pathways
Lopez: did a lot of focus groups before putting it together
"we did everything we had to know"
back and forth here about if the Friday was a criticism
Lopez: the school districts did the job of bringing the families
districts in some cases provided transportation
Robinson: "what do you need?"

Moriarty: school councils: to create more parent engagement
"I'm not sure after thirty years if this has come off as well as we'd hoped"
Engler Bennet: need to provide multiple vehicles for engagement
Stewart: site council finds under the purview of the school committee
"that's a big part of it"
Lopez: provide maximum opportunities to be successful

Plankey: love the fact this work is getting the spotlight that I think it deserves
certain point at which students can act as decision makers and advocates
to what extend were students participating?
Lopez: we tried to bring a group of youth; something we have to work on
Plankey: more opportunities
"I'd love to see students involved in this conversation"
notes expansion of statewide student voices: student advisory council; now also Mass Association of Student Reps, Mass Student Union 
would love to see actual student representation on school committees, back by a student advisory, as required by law 
Riley ties back to visioning committee

Stewart: parent involvement, engagement as envisioned by education reform law
would love to see student-led parent-teacher conferences
establish core beliefs, shared understanding from the start, bringing people to the table
notes her own seat is a result of long advocacy to ensure parent voice is at that table

Notes from the November Board of Elementary and Secondary Education: opening comments

 The agenda is here. The livestream will turn up over here.

there's a panel here and we don't know who it is or what they're talking about
okay, sounds like a gifted and talented panel of public testimony. Not sure that mic is on?
NAGE appears to be the organization testifying here: advanced learners, twice exceptional 
"languishing and nothing has improved in their schools"
asking for an adaptive MCAS; looking for a competency based system of education

Craven: looking at having a retreat in January or February
Stewart had mentioned implicit bias training; looking for additional items

Peyser: no report this week

Riley: safety coordinator doing podcast at national level on safety drills
DESE will be giving test kits for teachers and students for upcoming breaks
Boston: meetings
investigation on transportation for special education students; more information coming
will either clear or have a finding
continue to look at MCAS data: English learner data; and performance of boys
Craven: joint meeting of higher ed and K-12; tracking longitudinal outcome data
Hills: when next 'deliverables' from Boston?
Riley: were many over summer, now buses, bathrooms, data review in February
Hills: assume after that, more substantive reporting upcoming
"with respect to transportation, is DESE dealing with a complaint" or getting pulled into larger issue?
Riley: prior to complain, had other issues
Hills: "I don't know anything about transportation" but know about sole source
"working your way back up the funnel" to know why people didn't bid 
Riley: think it's something to be considered
"we, too, were surprised one person bid"
well, then you know nothing about this, clearly

Hills: Commissioner assessment committee: talk about criteria, process


Saturday, November 12, 2022

Passing along some mid-November notes from the superintendent

Are you following Dr. Monárrez on Twitter?

 

from the weekly updates to the School Committee:

  • It's been 100 days this week that Dr. Monárrez has been with us!

  • There's some discussion happening and to be had further around schools being used as polling places. 

  • Over 50 current staff members attended an information session on Performance Assessment for Leaders earlier this month. UPDATED for some more explanation: among the things an educator has to complete for a principal license are four tasks: data analysis; creation of a Professional Learning Community (PLC); supervision and evaluation (focusing on pre and post observation feedback) and family and community engagement. That's in addition to a 500 hour practicum. This session was designed to give aspiring principals more information ahead of Worcester forming another leadership cohort with a continued focus on diversifying our principalships.

  • The Worcester Educational Collaborative recently published a report on Worcester Public Schools and early college.

  • The Commissioner is moving forward the proposed Worcester Cultural Academy Charter Public School for the second state, which is an interview with the Department, public hearing. The administration will share with the School Committee that application once they have received it, and we'll coordinate response.
    Per the Superintendent's update: The Department will announce the date and details of the required public hearing in Worcester for the proposed WCACPS no later than Monday, November 14, 2022. In addition to a public hearing, the Department will also collect written public comment. Comments should be submitted by Wednesday, January 4, 2023 to: Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, c/o Office of Charter Schools and School Redesign, 75 Pleasant Street, Malden, MA 02148 or by email to charterschools@doe.mass.edu. Commissioner Riley will then review all of the materials and make his recommendation to the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education if he believes the proposal should receive a charter. The Board will vote at its February 2023 meeting if a recommendation has been made by the commissioner.
    I have many, many thoughts on this which I will share in a separate post at some point. This is coming from the same people that run the Old Sturbridge Village Charter School.

  • Note that the pause in accelerated repair funding announced by the MSBA last week will have an impact on what was being considered for Worcester East Middle School.

Friday, November 11, 2022

Notes from November Finance and Operations

 The video is over here; the agenda is here. 

As always, these are my notes as much for me as anyone!

The looming question of having all of this one-to-one technology now has been "and then what?" as all of it has a lifespan, and the one-time funds we used to fund it all were, well, one time. Thus the item that had the longest back up for this meeting this week.

These charts always make me panic me a little, as I find them initially hard to follow, but if you take some time with it, I think you'll work it out. Here's what we have now (this is page 18, as linked above); this is (listed down) what we have now, and then the bars show when they're 'done,' so to speak:


And here's the proposed (leased) replacement cycle (this is page 19 from above): 

The dollar amounts accumulate each year at the bottom, while each individual lease runs multiple years.

Now while this is (bottom line) $750K next year, note that it then goes to $1.6M, to $2.5M, to $3.4M, until in FY28, we're at what becomes a sustained $3.8M. As these are leases, this is an operational expenditure. This thus is a long-term plan for the budget to be regularly setting aside about $4M a year in replacement technology costs by FY28. 

You might remember a bit ago we updated our transportation policies in part because they talk about a "vendor" and we don't have one anymore, but also we had some missing pieces. One piece was policy EEAG, which covers student transportation in private vehicles. This is very much one of those "not having a policy won't save you" situations; we need to have language on this. Mr. Traynor sent some legal guidance back to us, and we'll be recommending, then, a policy that includes his addition. 

And so on to our regular transportation update. This month, we passed two milestones: we now have more full-sized bus drivers than routes (only a few, and remember, the margin is for keeping those routes going!), and MOST of the buses in the district are our new buses! Mr. Allen said that the hope is that by next month, all the new buses will be on site (even if some still need registration and inspection). All permits have been received for the new fueling station on Pullman Street; it's from the same landlord, so we're amending our lease. The hope is to have that operational for February. 
The crunch we (and not just us) have seen around athletic transportation--we've been able only to transport fall athletics after 4, as the first responsibility of the district is to get all students who get buses home from school--should not be an issue for winter (events are at night) and should be alleviated by spring, as we'll then have enough drivers to run both home from school routes and athletic routes at the same time. There is ongoing work with student behavior on buses, ensuring we have appropriate responses and supports. 
And speaking of replacement cycles, there's been a bit of a change of plan for the next set of buses. The School Committee voted to authorize administration to enter into a five year lease for up to 15 buses to replace our original set of buses. The plan was for those to be propane buses, as we make steps forward towards greener technology.
There's two things that have shifted though: first, the ordering time for new buses is so long that there's concern that we wouldn't get the new buses for when this current set of 13 is coming off their lease; plus the federal government changed the electric bus grant. As of now, the thinking is that the district will buy the leased buses (as part of FY24), apply for the federal grant, and see if we can (eventually--timelines on this one are long, too!) add 15 electric buses. We don't want to be running too many kinds of technology at the same time, either. 
Planned schedule for moving trainee drivers into service (which will shift and expand routes) in next month's meeting; Mr. Allen noted that the administration may be requesting additional training staff in order to be sure that those being trained can be moved most efficiently through the process.

Translation during School Committee meetings has been happening in Spanish for two meetings now; adding our other six major languages for our remaining fifteen meetings, estimated at a cost of $57,750, will be funded through ESSER this year, and then the estimated yearly cost of  $84,700 will be added to the FY24 budget. 

We also then attempted to sort out how it is that security guards are assigned to schools--in other words, what the process is. I don't know that I'm any clearer on that process now than I was before the meeting; you can watch the last 15 minutes to see if it makes it clear to you.

This meeting will report out on Thursday; we have back-to-back Worcester School Committee meetings this month, as we pushed our usual first week meeting back a week due to the joint superintendent-school committee conference. 

Most Americans now live in mixed-race neighborhoods

 I've had this piece, this analysis, really from the Washington Post open in a tab for a week now, waiting to be able to do something with it, because I think it's really important to a lot of things about how we live as Americans, education among them.

(Note, incidentally, that I've used a gift link for that; you don't need a subscription to the Washington Post to read it.)

The evaluation the Post did is based on this: 

When we say neighborhoods, we mean census tracts, which typically hold about 3,800 people. We created our tract data by rolling up even smaller block-level estimates to fit 2020 census tract boundaries, so that we could compare individual neighborhoods over time — something that’s not usually possible given the constantly shifting outlines of official census tracts.

 And they found this: 

Back in 1990, 78 percent of White people lived in predominantly White neighborhoods, where at least 4 of every 5 people were also White. In the 2020 Census, that’s plunged to 44 percent.

The piece has some great visuals on this--charts, maps, other things to play with--so I really urge you to take a look. 

I keep hoping to see someone take this up with the election results from Tuesday--if you see something, let me know?--because I'd be really interested if this had an impact both on attitude and access. It would seem to me that this make differences in both counts.

From an education perspective, of course, most children attend schools based on where they live. If where they live is more integrated, that makes a difference in the make-up of their schools. That's pretty huge.

From a Massachusetts perspective, we're tracking with the trend as a state: 


And a new 2020 majority in mixed neighborhoods is true both of what's nationally seen as metro Boston and the metro Worcester/Hartford thing. 
HOWEVER, if you zoom in on the map showing in which decade each county passed "most residents living in mixed race neighborhoods," and note that "never" is grey:

...it really depends where in Massachusetts you are. 
Anyway, neat stuff! Go look! 

and masking works

 ...go figure.

A new report released this week in the New England Journal of Medicine effectively used DESE's rescinding the mask requirement as an experiment: when that happened, many districts stopped requiring masks, but Boston and Chelsea didn't. The researchers looked at:

The final sample included 72 school districts, which comprised 294,084 students and 46,530 staff during the study period. The study period was defined as the 40 calendar weeks of the 2021–2022 school year, which ended on June 15, 2022 (the end of the last full reporting week in all districts).

And what did they find?

Before the statewide masking policy was rescinded, the trends in the incidence of Covid-19 observed in the Boston and Chelsea districts were similar to the trends in school districts that later lifted masking requirements. However, after the statewide masking policy was rescinded, the trends in the incidence of Covid-19 diverged, with a substantially higher incidence observed in school districts that lifted masking requirements than in school districts that sustained masking requirements. 

Specifically: 

 Overall, the lifting of masking requirements was associated with an additional 44.9 Covid-19 cases per 1000 students and staff (95% CI, 32.6 to 57.1) during the 15 weeks after the statewide masking policy was rescinded 

An editorial accompanying the research relates this to the massively inequitable costs of COVID. You can also find coverage on WGBH, The New York Times, The Washington Post.

And from one of the Twitter education satire accounts: