Wednesday, November 18, 2026

and somehow we still don't have a voucher call in Massachusetts

 But I think this today in State House News Service could be characterized as "leaning no"?

Every time it came up on the campaign trail this fall, Gov. Maura Healey said she was keeping an open mind and reviewing the federal scholarship tax credit that Republican gubernatorial nominee Mike Minogue championed. It is up to each state's governor whether to participate in the tax credit that allows eligible taxpayers to claim an annual credit of up to $1,700, or up to $3,400 for married couples filing jointly, for making donations to organizations that distribute K–12 education scholarships. Most states (including neighboring New York and New Hampshire) have opted in, but Healey said Tuesday she's still not sold on it being a good deal for Massachusetts. "I think the vast majority of us are still in the process of evaluating that," she said, though the Internal Revenue Service says at least 31 of 50 states have opted in as of Nov. 13. Healey added, "There's also a part of this which isn't talked about. The way it was drafted -- maybe as part of the initial, I haven't gone back to see all the different drafts of this -- but they are asking a lot of the states, and there's a lot of administrative work. There's a lot of administrative costs that isn't talked about that they've left to the states." Opposition to Massachusetts' participation in the federal tax credit program has come from teachers' unions and the Massachusetts Association of School Superintendents. Support has come from Minogue; the Pioneer Institute, a think tank that supports school choice policies; and from former Lt. Gov. Tim Murray and the Worcester Regional Chamber of Commerce, which he leads ... -- Colin A. Young

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

in case you ever wonder if your vote counts

This morning, one of the seats Lanesborough has on the Mount Greylock School Committee ended in a tie, as the final mail-in ballot (postmarked Election Day, so it counts!) had no write-ins in the race that required write in voting. 
That blank ballot would have been the deciding vote in a 743-743 tie, but instead, the seat is vacant, and the regional district will move forward with the appointment process for an empty seat. 

Board of Ed: budget committee

There isn't something to link to here...

Mohamed: 

Board members not receiving access to materials ahead of time
public not receiving materials ahead of Board meetings
Board members haven't received materials as requested as by her (as chair as budget chair)

rural schools
Commissioner's budget investment priorities
literacy act; statewide graduation requirements; educator workforce initiatives

Board of Ed: commissioner evaluation

 Smidy: in process of developing process similar to superintendent system
year long cycle: goal setting, midcycle review, summative in June
superintendent model has four standards; going to shift those to fit commissioner
four standards being worked with on legal
midcycle in January; full summative in May for report in June
each of four goals have specific benchmarks for completion over year

Board of Ed for November: regulations for MassCore and MyCAP

 after a welcome from Lawrence and a very fun upbeat song and dance number by student

proposed regulations can be found here

Board of Ed for November: opening comments

 The Board of Elementary and Secondary Education meets today at 9 in Lawrence. The agenda is here; the livestream is here. 

As I noted earlier, Chair Katherine Craven is making part of her opening comments a "Holocaust and Genocide Education Board Committee," harkening back to the Open Meeting Law violation of the Board regarding this same topic, when they deliberated public comment the Chair specifically invited on this topic. 

I will update this as we go, though I am not promising to catch every in and out of public comment remotely...

Sunday, November 15, 2026

and on the technology in education front

 The big state story, breaking at the end of last week, is that Secretary of Education Stephen Zrike, per WBUR reporting, recommended that Massachusetts public school districts look at Alpha Schools, whose approach, per a released email he found "thought-provoking."

...Zrike separately emailed roughly a dozen superintendents inviting them to a virtual presentation about the company's instructional model.

“While the model is not without controversy, I have attended several sessions with the Alpha team and found their approach thought-provoking,” Zrike wrote in the email to superintendents.

The education secretary said he wanted to gauge interest in partnerships with the company that could start as soon as that fall.

Zrike told superintendents in the email that the presentation was optional and that Alpha's model might not suit every district. He also noted the company's "substantial philanthropic support.”

In a statement Monday, Zrike said his office “regularly connects districts with outside organizations that might be helpful for teachers and students,” and local leaders can decide for themselves whether they want to proceed.

He cited Saga Education, which provides academic tutoring, and several other nonprofit organizations. Unlike Alpha, their programs do not rely on AI software to replace teacher-led instruction.

"These connections are meant to support innovation and strengthen public education,” he said in the statement.

(I'm still stuck on "several sessions"...)

It seems also to have at least in part been Zrike that brought Springfield's Kiley Prep in the Springfield Empowerment Zone into connection Alpha Schools, a model that fell apart after the Springfield schools' tech was hacked earlier this school year. 
And here we thought it was only Texas that would have state educational leadership working with Alpha Schools...

Meanwhile, that "innovation," as Fortune noted (using New York Times reporting) this weekend, isn't giving great results: 

Only 42% of Alpha students met the network’s goal of learning twice as fast in both math and reading, according to internal data first reported by The New York Times...Students who started behind fared worse. About a fifth of Alpha’s private school students scored at or below the 50th percentile nationally in math last fall, and only 37% of that group met the network’s 2x growth goal by winter, the Times found.

And those results are from the private school version of Alpha Schools, where the kids are from families that can afford to pay $75K a year!

I also don't want to let pass the connections "with outside organizations" above, for which the examples were all virtuously "nonprofit." Ed tech is big business; billions of dollars are spent by districts every year on technology. The degree to which most of this is the equivalent of streaming services, where there is no "thing" that is purchased and then owned, but instead an ongoing payment is made to an "outside organization" that holds and continues to hold the whatever-it-is the district is accessing, has blown up in the past decade. I strongly recommend reading Jessica Winter's latest piece for the New Yorker on this, entitled "The Technofeudalist Nightmare of K-12 Curricula."

...it it is also terribly strange that so many avatars of venture capital and private equity have been permitted to financialize public schools, which are neither designed nor intended to create profits or customers.

While the piece focuses on NYC schools, presume it to be as true of your local district.  

The Board of Ed meets Tuesday: here comes the new graduation requirements (for districts)

The Board of Ed meets Tuesday for their regular monthly meeting. It is another month they're going on the road, this time to Lawrence High School (thus to one of the two districts under state receivership, though that is not on the agenda). 

Chair Craven, moving well outside the oversight of the Board, appears to be appointing a "Holocaust and Genocide Education Board Committee." Recall that this topic is of course under the state standards as established by actual educators. Last time the Chair brought this before the Board, the Board violated the Open Meeting Law, as it was public comment invited by the Chair that then was deliberated; one assumes that is why it is on the agenda. 

Also of note, in the Commissioner's update is "Accountability Determinations," which were not updated as part of the MCAS and accountability release in September. That it has come back suggests to me that updates are probably coming; one might watch this space.

Continuing to barrel forward with regulatory changes that require district action, the Commissioner at this meeting is recommending to the Board that they send out for public comment regulations that would require all districts offer MassCore and MyCAP for--and this is the stunning part--next school year! It's genuinely wild to me the disconnect between that and the headlines we're already seeing about next school year's budget woes. Also, can the Board actually require that districts offer particular things? I haven't seen any legal analysis of this authority; I'd be interested. 

There's also, though this as yet has no backup, a "Report from the Commissioner's Performance Evaluation Committee" perhaps setting goals for the coming year?

I plan to cover this one remotely, as I have other obligations Tuesday morning. 

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

What an election! Some education paths forward


*This would be a good day for Governor Maura Healey to announce that Massachusetts will not opt in.

a quick round-up on some things I've been reading

 So much to cover, so little time...


*Honeytrap: (per the OED)Originally in espionage, now esp. in Journalism: a stratagem in which an attractive person (usually a woman) entices another (usually a man) into revealing information.
"Honeypot" is Winnie the Pooh.

**Contrast with this from last night's Worcester City Council meeting:



Wednesday, November 4, 2026

And speaking of not good news: SCOTUS hears St. Mary's v. Roy

 While your attention may have been on the election, the Supreme Court held arguments yesterday in St. Mary's v Roy, a case out of Colorado in which the central question is if a Catholic preschool which receives public funds may discriminate against LGBTQ families. 

While I always await Chris Geidner over at Law Dork, both Chalkbeat and K-12 Dive have coverage worth reviewing, Frankly, it looks pretty bleak. 

And now for the not-so-good news from the election

My hearty congratulations to those across the country who brought in national, state, and local leadership that will better support public education!

(including Texas, where a former school board member will serve as the next Governor!)

If you're rejoicing this morning in the blue tsunami that swept the nation last night, I do not wish to take away from your joy, but I do want to point to some election results on ballot initiatives that are not good for kids.

I will update this when or if I find more.

Monday, November 2, 2026

Proposed early literacy regulations now open for public comment

My laptop ran out of battery power at last week's Board of Ed meeting, so there were two sections I didn't cover: the Commissioner's evaluation, which I do not think I can summarize, and the proposed early literacy regulations. 
Those regulations have now been released for public comment per the Board vote last week. As I noted way back when I wrote about this in February of 2024, how we teach reading has become a crusade: the old way must be entirely vanquished and no one who REALLY cares about children would think otherwise.
It is, of course, not that simple, as teaching humans usually is not the simple.
Massachusetts, unfortunately, rather than learning from the early adopters of this crusade--Mississippi, anyone?--has barreled ahead, and now we have a law that mandates that all early elementary students be taught from the curricula described in the law and no other. Waivers, while provided by the law, were, the Board was told last week, only rarely going to be granted.*

This now necessitates regulations. Note that the regulations are being put before the Board:
  • despite the actual list of curricula that qualifies not yet being available (it appears to not yet fully exists)
  • despite the free curricula that DESE is required to provide to the estimated 40% of districts that will have to switch curricula not yet being available
Thus we do not really know what it is we're responding to. There is not--no, really not--an anathema definition so clear we all can know without further information what is included. And keeping in mind that it is "three cuing" that is barred, something we includes, and I am not making this up, suggesting that children might look at the pictures in their books, we are in a realm of akin to "Alice in Wonderland." One feels a bit as if one is talking to the Caterpillar when one listens to this being described. 
the Tenniel illustration via Project Gutenberg**

In any case, now is the time to comment on the proposed regulation. 

*this led to a rare mention of school committees by the Board; there was a question as to if school committees would have to vote for a district to pursue a waiver. It appears some Board members wanted this to be required, as they were under the impression that having the district have to make pursuing a waiver public would be unpopular.
Those under this impression greatly are misled about the relative popularity of the Department versus most local school committees with their local communities
. 
**yes, I am well aware of the subtext here. No, I am not implying anything additional here. 


Friday, October 30, 2026

Cannot be aesthetically integrated: updates on Secretary Linda McMahon

we're thinking of getting tee shirts...

  • You may have caught that Secretary of Education Linda McMahon spent $43,000 on furniture for the office she purports to be vacating, as the current furniture "cannot be configurationally or aesthetically integrated” into new space.
    If you're supposed to be making your job go away entirely, surely you can put up with the old desk in the meantime? 
  • Just today, AFT announced that they are suing McMahon over the mismanagement of public service loan forgiveness. This makes something like seven lawsuits that AFT has filed against the federal government.

  • Also on the Secretary McMahon lawsuit front, something that didn't get a lot of mainstream press, so full marks to the wrestling world here, but the effort of she and her (still though separated) husband Vince McMahon to get the lawsuit against them for the sexual abuse of minors that happened while they were running WWE has failed. As quite appropriately noted by the article here linked: 
    Despite allegedly being aware of abuse to minors and not preventing it, Linda McMahon serves as Secretary of Education in Donald Trump’s administration.  
  • And while we're doing McMahon news, be sure to read Matt Barnum McMahon's "make American education great again" and its relationship with reality. Our revolution on education has always been the access provided to public education, and even that quite unevenly. The bit that I found most telling: regarding that federal "intrusion" in education:

    There is good evidence students have benefited from these efforts, and the laws have become foundational to American education. 

 

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Top seven moments of Tuesday's Board of Ed meeting

  1.  Hampshire Regional High School's Select Chorus singing “the world is sustained by three things: justice, peace, and truth,” asserting it is a message that is important "in these times."

  2. Anne T. Dunphy Principal Stacey Jenkins, responding to a question posed by the Department, testifying that there was no program or "out-of-the-box" reason that the district's chronic absenteeism rate has improved. It was an all-school focus on "how are the children?"

  3. Commissioner Martinez noting how beautiful the ride west on Route 2 is this time of year. 

  4. Student member Sara Khan, responding to the SIGNIFICANT new requirements being proposed by the Department for high schools, observing "this is going to be hard" for districts that don't already have MassCore or use MyCap; that her school and others are laying off teachers, not hiring them, and districts do not have the money for this.

  5. Member Kristin Smidy commenting that "student buy-in" on the planning required in MyCap is a question; that its use is questionable if students don't find it meaningful or useful. 

  6. Member Matt Hills considering both himself and his children in ninth grade and the degree to which this (MyCap) would have been useful/meaningful/something they were invested in and not simply a new way of tracking students.

  7. Chair Katherine Craven observing that "the danger is" that districts will see all of the above as an unfunded mandate and simply not do it.
The mill village of Haydenville is where Williamsburg keeps their Dunkin'


Board of Ed for October: graduation standards

There is this memo which isn't particularly revelatory, but then there is a large PowerPoint that is not online. As the memo says:

The agency is currently developing guidance and tools to support districts towards full implementation of the proposed graduation framework. 

I am again going to point out that "fully implementing" a "proposed framework" that has yet to go through a legislative process makes no sense.

"the agency setting conditions to change practices in the field" is the theme of this year, says Commissioner Martinez

introducing MyCap and MassCore
And then hearing from researchers

regulations that the Department will bring forward for discussion next month on what?

"clarification" says Woo, that regulations proposed next month will set up requirements for what schools "must offer," not what individual students must complete

Board of Ed for October: State Student Advisory Council

 The backup provided is here, though it doesn't tell us anything

Sara Khan speaking to this from slides that are hard to see
SSAC Summer Leadership retreat
analyzed a lot of data, data gathering and analyzing


Board of Ed for October: opening comments, coming to you from Williamsburg

 The Board of Ed is here today: 

The Anne T. Dunphy School in Williamsburg (which is northwest of Northampton; it's next on Route 9, heading west).
As always, with a board that largely lives inside of 128, the meeting is posted to start later (9:30) and is going to start later than that. Many comments about the location as people come in.

The agenda is here. 

I will update as we go here.

Sunday, October 25, 2026

There's more than miles between us and a new set of graduation standards

 (the above is an adaptation of a line from Lil' Abner that I cannot now find anywhere online)

As a blogger who started writing out of sheer frustration with local school district governance coverage, I have a certain amount of weary understanding of the misses that happen. This is particularly true given the undercutting of the Fourth Estate and the seemingly endless churn of local reporters (when we have them at all!) for local news coverage. 

I nonetheless was puzzled by coverage of the October 8 Worcester School Committee meeting, which appeared to take as given that the graduation report from last year was moving forward into implementation.

As we have discussed here before, more than once, this is not the case. The Department does not have the authority to create new required graduation standards. The authority to determine what a student needs to graduate remains with local school committees. The competency determination, as bound by the amended law under Question 2, is within the Department's authority, and districts now all have policies that align to that. That is, though, the full extend of the authority of the Department.

Now, I'm pretty sure--I think?--that those running things here in Worcester know that, but I remain concerned that some writing for the Department might not. Recently, every superintendent received a communication from DESE that gave a deadline of late November for a report on where individual high schools were on their graduation requirements relating to the graduation report. It referred to this Companion Guide for information. 

And nowhere in any of this was there any mention of the fact that the Department cannot simply implement the graduation report, lacking utterly the authority to do so. It takes the graduation report as something that is being implemented, and this, despite the report itself--though only v-e-r-y subtly!--noting that the Legislature would need to act for implementation.

And if you think the Legislature is simply going to pass the graduation report as issued into legislation, well, I wouldn't advise putting money on that. 

While I have come to expect this sort of confusion of local reporters who often just got there, I am troubled to see it from the regulatory agency. 


UPDATE: The backup for Tuesday's Board of Ed meeting now has this memo, which continues the "the report is a recommendation which we are working to implement" without mention of the Department not having the authority to do so.